<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1204737666323810&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1" alt="facebook">
Skip to content

Resources

Q Report Resources

Explore Q Report's Content Centre for expert advice on jewellery insurance. You can also read e-guides and blogs, watch videos and more.

Explore Q Report's Content Centre for expert advice on jewellery insurance. You can also read e-guides and blogs, watch videos and more.

Jewellery, engagement ring & watch advice, plus insurance tips & industry insights. 

Watch expert tips, discover insurance benefits & hear real customer stories. 

Find answers to common questions about jewellery, engagement ring & watch insurance. 

Click here to access important policy documents - Product Disclosure Statement, Financial Services Guide, and Policy Wording.

Click here to access the Target Market Determination (TMD) document.

Get Your Quote

Men, Size Matters: The Truth Behind Carat Weight

Q Report Team

Updated on March 19, 2025
Related Posts
Featured Posts
form-profile
Jewellery Insurance

Instant Quote
play-audio
Listen to article
/

When it comes to diamonds, there is definitely some truth behind this statement. Let’s delve deeper though and see just how much weight is given to carat weight and whether bigger is always better.

Size vs Quality

There is no doubt that a lot of women will tell you it’s quality not quantity. Others prefer a larger stone and are happy to compromise on quality, with the view that once it’s on their finger, the naked eye may not actually be able to distinguish between quality grades. Some woman prefer jewellery that will make a statement. Others might actually be embarrassed by a big stone.

There is no right or wrong answer. Finding that perfect diamond ring depends largely on personal preferences and priorities (and of course, your budget).

What Does the Research Say

One of the top internet sites selling diamond engagement rings conducted a survey of almost 4000 men and woman in the engagement ring target market. The data that was collected was analysed to determine a whole variety of diamond engagement preferences.

Interestingly, what mattered the most when selecting a diamond ring was the design of the ring. Second and third priorities were diamond quality and ring craftsmanship.

It’s probably no surprise that men and women differed greatly with regards to their preferences. The results showed that 49% of women rated design as the number one factor whilst 30% of men saw it that way. In terms of diamond quality and craftsmanship, men placed a higher importance on this factor.

Against popular belief, the size of the diamond was one of the least important factor, with 6% of women and 8% of men caring most about the size of the diamond. This doesn’t necessarily mean that they want a smaller stone though. It’s also important to note that this is one of many surveys that have been conducted on this controversial debate.

 

Diamond carat chart

 

What Else is Important When it Comes to Carat Weight

All things being equal, the round diamond is more expensive compared to all other shapes of diamonds. One of the reasons for this, is that face up, it displays the largest diameter for its weight. In simple terms, if you compare a 1 carat round brilliant cut diamond to a 1 carat princess cut diamond, the round will look bigger in the ring.

You then need to determine whether it is the actual weight of the diamond or the visual appearance of size that it significant to you.

It’s important to note that weight does not always correlate to a bigger looking diamond. A diamond that is poorly cut in order to maximise its weight may not allow effective reflection of light from one edge of the diamond to the other. This can give the appearance of a smaller looking diamond and can also diminish its beauty and sparkle.

So while a bigger diamond may be your preference, it’s important to ensure that the cut quality is not unknowingly compromised, as a poorly cut diamond will never have the same sparkle as a well-cut stone.

It’s a Matter of Personal Preference

Clearly there is no one answer. It comes down to personal preference (and budget of course). It’s one thing to know your personal preference, but your partner’s preference is what really matters.

She is the one that will be wearing this ring everyday for the rest of her life and will look at it as a symbol of your love for her. You might hear her making a passing comment about the size of a diamond she sees on someone else. Take note. If all she has ever dreamt of is that 1 carat stone, then you may not want to disappoint her by giving her a high quality 0.50 carat stone. Listen to her preference.

At the end of the day, the size of the diamond is only factor. You have the ability to find that perfect balance of the 4C’s that both fits within your budget and that she will love forever. You don’t have to do it alone. See a Q Certified jeweller in your area who can assist you find that perfect engagement ring.

New call-to-action

Purchase Amount

To get an accurate insurance quote, please provide the amount from your purchase receipt.

Don't have the receipt?

If you don't have the receipt, you can provide the most recent valuation amount instead.

OK
Related Posts
Featured Posts
avatar_light
Jewellery Insurance

Instant Quote
play-audio
Listen to article
/

When it comes to diamonds, there is definitely some truth behind this statement. Let’s delve deeper though and see just how much weight is given to carat weight and whether bigger is always better.

Size vs Quality

There is no doubt that a lot of women will tell you it’s quality not quantity. Others prefer a larger stone and are happy to compromise on quality, with the view that once it’s on their finger, the naked eye may not actually be able to distinguish between quality grades. Some woman prefer jewellery that will make a statement. Others might actually be embarrassed by a big stone.

There is no right or wrong answer. Finding that perfect diamond ring depends largely on personal preferences and priorities (and of course, your budget).

What Does the Research Say

One of the top internet sites selling diamond engagement rings conducted a survey of almost 4000 men and woman in the engagement ring target market. The data that was collected was analysed to determine a whole variety of diamond engagement preferences.

Interestingly, what mattered the most when selecting a diamond ring was the design of the ring. Second and third priorities were diamond quality and ring craftsmanship.

It’s probably no surprise that men and women differed greatly with regards to their preferences. The results showed that 49% of women rated design as the number one factor whilst 30% of men saw it that way. In terms of diamond quality and craftsmanship, men placed a higher importance on this factor.

Against popular belief, the size of the diamond was one of the least important factor, with 6% of women and 8% of men caring most about the size of the diamond. This doesn’t necessarily mean that they want a smaller stone though. It’s also important to note that this is one of many surveys that have been conducted on this controversial debate.

 

Diamond carat chart

 

What Else is Important When it Comes to Carat Weight

All things being equal, the round diamond is more expensive compared to all other shapes of diamonds. One of the reasons for this, is that face up, it displays the largest diameter for its weight. In simple terms, if you compare a 1 carat round brilliant cut diamond to a 1 carat princess cut diamond, the round will look bigger in the ring.

You then need to determine whether it is the actual weight of the diamond or the visual appearance of size that it significant to you.

It’s important to note that weight does not always correlate to a bigger looking diamond. A diamond that is poorly cut in order to maximise its weight may not allow effective reflection of light from one edge of the diamond to the other. This can give the appearance of a smaller looking diamond and can also diminish its beauty and sparkle.

So while a bigger diamond may be your preference, it’s important to ensure that the cut quality is not unknowingly compromised, as a poorly cut diamond will never have the same sparkle as a well-cut stone.

It’s a Matter of Personal Preference

Clearly there is no one answer. It comes down to personal preference (and budget of course). It’s one thing to know your personal preference, but your partner’s preference is what really matters.

She is the one that will be wearing this ring everyday for the rest of her life and will look at it as a symbol of your love for her. You might hear her making a passing comment about the size of a diamond she sees on someone else. Take note. If all she has ever dreamt of is that 1 carat stone, then you may not want to disappoint her by giving her a high quality 0.50 carat stone. Listen to her preference.

At the end of the day, the size of the diamond is only factor. You have the ability to find that perfect balance of the 4C’s that both fits within your budget and that she will love forever. You don’t have to do it alone. See a Q Certified jeweller in your area who can assist you find that perfect engagement ring.

New call-to-action

Table of Contents

Introduction
Understanding the 4 Cs of Diamonds
Diamond Shapes
Choosing a Ring Style
Selecting a Ring Retailer

Understanding Mechanical Movements

Rolex-super-precision

Unlike their battery-powered quartz counterparts, luxury watches have a beating heart – the mechanical movement. First created in the 14th century, large, weight-driven tower clocks with verge escapements and foliot balances marked the dawn of mechanical timekeeping.

Today, the core concept of mechanical movements remains unchanged from its original conception. It involves an intricate arrangement of gears, springs, and an escapement powered by a wound mainspring. This precision engineering allows for smooth operation and precise timekeeping.

Manual watch movements require the wearer to wind the crown periodically. Automatic watch movements, on the other hand, utilise the wearer's movements to keep the mainspring wound, offering a convenient everyday solution.

The Patek Philippe Calatrava, with its ultra-thin manual movement, exemplifies the elegance of traditional watchmaking. On the other hand, the Rolex Oyster Perpetual, with its self-winding mechanism epitomises practicality and durability.

Whether manual or automatic, a mechanical movement imbues a luxury watch with a soul, a testament to human ingenuity and a treasured heirloom for generations to come

Luxury Watch Complications: Exploring Hidden Features & Functionality

Luxury watches often boast 'complications,' intricate mechanisms that add layers of sophistication, style and utility. Here, we explore some of the most fascinating complications created by the best luxury watch brands.

Statistic Heading

Rolex-super-precision

Unlike their battery-powered quartz counterparts, luxury watches have a beating heart – the mechanical movement. First created in the 14th century, large, weight-driven tower clocks with verge escapements and foliot balances marked the dawn of mechanical timekeeping.

Today, the core concept of mechanical movements remains unchanged from its original conception. It involves an intricate arrangement of gears, springs, and an escapement powered by a wound mainspring. This precision engineering allows for smooth operation and precise timekeeping.

Manual watch movements require the wearer to wind the crown periodically. Automatic watch movements, on the other hand, utilise the wearer's movements to keep the mainspring wound, offering a convenient everyday solution.

The Patek Philippe Calatrava, with its ultra-thin manual movement, exemplifies the elegance of traditional watchmaking. On the other hand, the Rolex Oyster Perpetual, with its self-winding mechanism epitomises practicality and durability.

Whether manual or automatic, a mechanical movement imbues a luxury watch with a soul, a testament to human ingenuity and a treasured heirloom for generations to come

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Common Diamond Alternatives
for Engagement Rings

Tanzanite

Contents insurance is essential for anyone who owns valuable items, as it helps protect you should a potential loss occur in your.

Aquamarine

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in

Sapphire

Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum voluptate velit esse.

Luxury Watch Complications: Exploring Hidden Features & Functionality

Luxury watches often boast 'complications,' intricate mechanisms that add layers of sophistication, style and utility. Here, we explore some of the most fascinating complications created by the best luxury watch brands.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

Peace of Mind: An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

“Knowing your engagement ring is insured brings peace of mind. Accidents can happen, and insurance coverage alleviates the worry and stress of potential loss or damage.”

Unlike their battery-powered quartz counterparts, luxury watches have a beating heart – the mechanical movement. First created in the 14th century, large, weight-driven tower clocks with verge escapements and foliot balances marked the dawn of mechanical timekeeping.

Today, the core concept of mechanical movements remains unchanged from its original conception. It involves an intricate arrangement of gears, springs, and an escapement powered by a wound mainspring. This precision engineering allows for smooth operation and precise timekeeping.

Manual watch movements require the wearer to wind the crown periodically. Automatic watch movements, on the other hand, utilise the wearer's movements to keep the mainspring wound, offering a convenient everyday solution.

The Patek Philippe Calatrava, with its ultra-thin manual movement, exemplifies the elegance of traditional watchmaking. On the other hand, the Rolex Oyster Perpetual, with its self-winding mechanism epitomises practicality and durability.

Whether manual or automatic, a mechanical movement imbues a luxury watch with a soul, a testament to human ingenuity and a treasured heirloom for generations to come

Export
Expert Tip

Budget Considerations

Diamond shapes can vary in price due to popularity and demand. Round brilliants, for example, tend to be more expensive than other shapes due to their high demand. If budget is a concern, consider alternative shapes or prioritise other aspects, such as cut quality, over the shape itself.

Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet. Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet.Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet.Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet.

Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet.

Amet minim mollit non deserunt ullamco est sit aliqua dolor do amet sint. Velit officia consequat duis enim velit mollit. Exercitation veniam consequat sunt nostrud amet.

Jewellery Insurance FAQ

Contents insurance covers the items within your home in case they are damaged, lost or stolen. This can include furniture, electronics, clothing and other personal.  Contents insurance is essential for anyone who owns valuable items, as it helps protect you should a potential loss occur in your.

Contents insurance covers the items within your home in case they are damaged, lost or stolen. This can include furniture, electronics, clothing and other personal.  Contents insurance is essential for anyone who owns valuable items, as it helps protect you should a potential loss occur in your.
Home Security Fortification

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised.

Travel Savvy

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised.

Social Media Caution

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised.

Regular Valuations

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised engagement ring insurance provides financial protection in the event of loss, theft or damage by ensuring you can recover the ring's monetary value or repair or replace.

An engagement ring is a significant financial and sentimental investment. Specialised.

bulb
0%

Contents insurance is essential for anyone who owns valuable items, as it helps protect you should a potential loss occur in your.

Luxury Watch Complications: Exploring Hidden Features & Functionality

Luxury watches often boast 'complications,' intricate mechanisms that add layers of sophistication, style and utility. Here, we explore some of the most fascinating complications created by the best luxury watch brands.

Home Security Fortification

Contents insurance covers the items within your home in case they are damaged, lost or stolen. This can include furniture, electronics, clothing and other personal.  Contents insurance is essential for anyone who owns valuable items, as it helps protect you should a potential loss occur in your.

Purchase Amount

To get an accurate insurance quote, please provide the amount from your purchase receipt.

Don't have the receipt?

If you don't have the receipt, you can provide the most recent valuation amount instead.

OK

More Articles